It’s cookie season! I was excited to share these pretty little thumbprint cookies. Thumbprints are so versatile because you can use pretty much any cookie dough and filling, so there are endless flavor combinations to be had.
To make these extra simple, I started with a box mix. I have no shame in reaching for a cookie or cake mix for recipes that I want to keep as fast and easy as possible. They are fun to use when experimenting with flavors also because they cut your prep time in half. I like the Krusteaz gingerbread mix because the cookie is super soft and chewy and the molasses flavor is mild, which is great for those who aren’t into a super spicy cookie.
I filled these cookies with a smooth buttery rum filling – they just scream Christmas.
I rolled the dough balls in coarse sugar sprinkles and raw brown sugar before baking. It added a pleasant sugary crunch to each bite.
| Gingerbread Thumbprint Cookies with Butter Rum Filling | | Print |
- FOR THE COOKIES:
- 1 box Krusteaz gingerbread cookie mix, or similar
- 1 egg
- 1 stick butter, softened to room temperature
- Coarse sugar sprinkles or raw brown sugar, for rolling (optional)
- FOR THE FILLING:
- 1 cup powdered sugar
- 1-2 tablespoons of dark rum
- ½ stick of butter, softened to room temperature
- FOR THE COOKIES:
- Preheat oven to 350F
- Prepare cookie dough according to mix instructions (this will use the butter and egg if using a Krusteaz mix)
- Use a small cookie scoop (approx 2 tsp per cookie) to form dough balls. If desired, roll the balls in coarse sugar sprinkles or raw brown sugar.
- Place dough balls 2 inches apart on ungreased cookie sheet. Make indention in the center of each ball using your thumb or the handle of a spatula.
- Bake 7-10 minutes until edges are lightly brown and dough starts to crackle.
- Remove from oven. If indentations have filled in while baking, use your finger to press them back down while cookies are still hot.
- Cool on cooling rack.
- FOR THE FILLING:
- Whisk together all ingredients until smooth. It should be the consistency of a thin frosting. If filling is too thick, add additional rum a few drops at a time to thin. If your filling is too thin, add additional powdered sugar 1 tsp at a time to thicken.
- Spoon small amounts of filling into indentations. Top with additional sugar or sprinkles if desired. Allow to set and then store in airtight container.
Krusteaz Cookie Mix & Holiday Giveaway
You can win your own prize pack of cookie mixes and fun kitchen items from Krusteaz! One reader will win two boxes EACH of the cookie mixes shown above: butter vanilla sugar, gingerbread, oatmeal scotchie, shortbread, and snickerdoodle. In addition, the prize pack will contain some other fun items like an apron, tote bag, holiday cookie cutters, and a frosting decorating pen!
The giveaway runs from now until Monday, December 14th at 11:59pm Eastern. Winner will be contacted via email!
Here’s how to enter:
- Leave a comment on this post and tell me your favorite Christmas cookie! – mandatory
- Follow @ebrowniebites (me!) and @krusteaz on Instagram – optional for an extra entry. Leave an additional comment telling me you’ve followed both accounts or are already a follower!
- Tweet about this giveaway! Make sure to tag @erinbrowne and link to this blog post. Here’s a shortened link to use: http://goo.gl/IL6cxF – optional for an extra entry. Leave an additional comment with a link to your tweet!
- Subscribe to our email updates! Find the sign-up box in the sidebar. – optional for an extra entry. Leave an additional comment telling me you’ve subscribed or that you are already a subscriber!
Good luck everyone!!
Here’s a handy Pinterest-optimized image for you if you want to save this recipe for later – just hover your mouse over the image and click “Pin it”!
You Might Like These Posts:
No Bake White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies | Peanut Butter & Co. Review
Chewy Old-Fashioned Molasses Cookies
Soft Butter Cake Mix Cookies
Easy Christmas Cookie Decorating Ideas and GIVEAWAY!
Soft Vanilla Bean Frosted Sugar Cookies (Lofthouse Copycat)
Low Carb Keto Peanut Butter Cookies
Peanut Butter Pretzel Crunch Cookie Butter
Chocolate Chip Pudding Cookies
Can I use the 21oz Betty Crocker cookie mix to make these? Would I have to alter any ingredients?
Yes! Instead of using the butter and egg listed in my ingredients, just prepare the Betty Crocker mix as directed on the box, and then proceed with the butter rum filling ingredients and instructions as written. :)
Follow @ebrowniebites (me!) and @krusteaz on Instagram as rajeespot
Did you ever make the frosting and it was chunky? I thought I waited long enough for the butter, but maybe not? What do you think? Thank you!
https://twitter.com/momsfocus/status/676642058849808385
Ginger cookies
Tweet – https://twitter.com/mom2boys51/status/676611351146397697
I follow both on Instagram – mom2boys51
Sugar cookies with icing are my favorite Christmas cookie.
Love frosted sugar cut out cookies!!
I like to have oatmeal raisin cookies.
My favorite Christmas cookie is Sugar Cookies
I like sugar cookies
My favorite Christmas cookie is the good ole sugar cookie. Its a classic for a reason. Thank you!
My favorite type of cookies for this time of year are snickerdoodles.
I like sugar cookies.
I subscribe to your email updates!
Tweeted: https://twitter.com/davisesq212/status/676174769260240896
I follow Follow @ebrowniebites and @krusteaz on Instagram
My favorite Christmas cookie is gingerbread!
My fav is peanut butter cookies.
I like chocolate chip.
i am an email subscriber
gingerbread cookies are my favorite Christmas cookies. i love them.
My favorite Christmas cookie is Snickerdoodles.
My favorite Christmas cookie is chocolate crinkle cookies.
I love a good old-fashioned gingerbread man. Nom.
My favorite is oatmeal raisin.
I like chocolate chip cookies and brown sugar cookies with browned butter icing!
I was already a follower of you and Krusteaz on instagram as sbshortie
I love chocolate crinkle cookies. They are so delicious.
Appreciation to my father who told me about this webpage, this web
site is really amazing.
Ginger cookies are my favorite
I love Oreo Cookie Balls! :D
I love date pinwheel cookies.
Already subscribed to Brownie Bites Blog email updates.
Already following ebrowniebites and krusteaz on Instagram {cherylfahling}.
My favorite Christmas cookies are Italian Wedding Cookies (aka Cocoa Wedding Cakes or Snowball Cookies).
I loooove snickerdoodle cookies!!!
My favorite Christmas cookie is snickerdoodles
My favorite cookie is a sugar cookie with frosting and sprinkles.
My favorite Christmas cookie is gingerbread.
My favorite Christmas cookie is my favorite anytime cookie-chocolate chip!
I subscribed by email.
Tweeted: https://twitter.com/mariecal123/status/674227186677760000
I follow both on instagram @calvadeana
My favorite holiday cookie is Gingerbread Men!
My favorite Christmas cookie is sugar cookies with frosting.
I love red and green chocolate chip cookies.
I like the peanut butter cookies with chocolate kisses.
Gingerbread cookies are my favorite holiday ones.
i love milk chocolate macadamia lace cookies, but i have no idea how to make them!
email subscriber
I love those butter spritz cookies with colored sugar.
My favorite Christmas cookie? There are these amazing sugar cookies that I used to get every year for Christmas at my former employer. They were the perfect pillowy soft melty sugar cookies with the best icing on top! I refused to share those bad boys with anyone.