How To Throw a Nostalgic 90s Themed Party

Retro Food And Cassette Labels by Endless Bliss Blog
I love the idea of painting cassettes (or just leaving them plain and writing on the labels) for the food labels! And you HAVE to have Bagel Bites and Pizza Rolls for a 90s party.

DIY Lunchable Trays by Event OTB
OMG how perfect are these? And let’s be honest, probably way cheaper than buying enough Lunchables for all of your guests. But you could totally place a few packages of the real things around on the table for effect.

Authentic Cafeteria Pizza
Nothing takes you right back to 90s school cafeterias like a slab of Rectangle Pizza, and here’s the actual handwritten recipe so you can make your own for your party. Serve it on some actual cafeteria trays with chocolate milk cartons and canned corn for the full experience.

Homemade DIY Dunkaroo Dip by Garnish and Glaze
You may not be able to get the real thing anymore, but this is a very convincing substitute that will make your 90’s-loving guests squeal with delight.

DIY 90s-inspired cake by Club Crafted
If this isn’t the most 90s cake you’ve ever seen, I don’t know what is.

THE Nickelodeon Slime Cake
Okay, who remembers this from the original Nickelodeon Magazine, and especially the mentions in the old commercials promoting the mag? Now you can make your own at home, and, uh, I totally want to do this.

Assorted 90s Snacks
This is probably the easiest party theme to stock with a variety of nostalgic packaged snacks. Though a lot of items may not be available anymore, the ones that are would make a fantastic snack spread – make sure to use the packaging as part of the decor!

DIY Lisa Frank Zebra Cakes by Studio DIY
These are perfect, that is all.

Butterfly Pretzels by Butter With A Side of Bread
I mean, did you even live in the 90s if you didn’t wear butterfly clips?

Furby Cake DIY
OMG, I have no words!!

Paint Splatter Rice Krispies Treats uploaded by Pinterest user Ideas4EandI
Take homemade (or premade!) Rice Krispies treats, push a lollipop stick in the end, cover it in coating chocolate, and drizzle with various bright colors of coating chocolate. How 90s is this? I daresay it’d be even more 90s if you used white coating chocolate instead.

And now I have to just show you guys some 90s cakes for inspiration for making your own, because these are awesome and I can’t NOT share them.

90s Cake by Flavourtown Bakery UK

Nickelodeon Cake by Etsy user Pie’s Cake Shop

Clueless Cake by Frosted Memory Maker

90s Birthday Cake by Las Vegas Custom Cakes

Jazz Print Party Cups – Find them Here
Just seeing this pattern smacks me dead in the face with nostalgia. You cannot throw a 90s themed party and not serve your drinks in these babies.

Slap Bracelets – Find Them Here
The perfect party favors!

I Love The 90’s Party Plates – Find Them Here
Load up these plates with fruit roll-ups, Funyuns, and Pizza Rolls, baby!

Gold Chain Mylar Balloons – Find Them Here
These are so deliciously 90’s that I want to string them all over my house even though I’m not having a party. Anyone wanna come over?

90s Photo Booth Props – Find Them Here
If you’re not setting up a photo booth to let your guests get that perfect photo for the ‘gram, you’re partying wrong.

90s Dress-Up Clothing – Browse Here
That shirt on the right… I NEED IT! Click the link above to go down the nostalgia rabbit hole of 90’s attire. I want it all.