Pull on some leggings and grab your boots, because it's pumpkin spice season! I love these cute little frozen yogurt bites. They're a good option for a healthy treat for both grown-ups and kiddos. Keep them in the freezer and grab a few when you're feeling a little peckish and they'll help tide you over until the next meal time.
The drops are made from simple ingredients - Greek yogurt, honey, a bit of vanilla, and pumpkin spice peanut butter. That's it! Just make sure that your yogurt is fresh to get the best outcome (know more about greek yogurt starter culture here). I use this peanut butter every fall and we love it!! It has actual pumpkin in it in addition to the warm spices that give it that signature pumpkin pie-y flavor. It's a fun way to add some fall tastes into our regular uses for peanut butter.
... and we use a lot of peanut butter in this house.
They're piped onto some wax paper and frozen for a bit, and then transferred into a bag to keep in the freezer. You can use any pastry tip you want to vary the shape and size. I made mine roughly the size of standard M&M's and I got about 180 drops.
Pumpkin Spice Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt Bites
- Total Time: 5 mins
- Yield: 180 small drops
Ingredients
- ¾ cup Greek yogurt (see notes)
- ¼ heaping cup Pumpkin Spice Peanut Butter
- 2 tsp honey
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
Instructions
- Mix all ingredients until smooth.
- Place mixture in a pastry bag fitted with round or star tip of your choice. Alternatively, you can place the mixture in a Ziploc bag and snip off the corner with a pair of scissors.
- Cover a large cookie sheet with a piece of wax paper. Pipe dollops onto the paper and place into the freezer for 2-3 hours until firm, and then transfer to a freezer safe bag or container. Keep frozen.
Notes
Greek yogurt is thicker than regular, so if you use regular you may need to increase the amount of peanut butter used so that the mixture can be piped.
If you are concerned about plain Greek yogurt being too tangy, try a lightly-sweetened vanilla flavor instead.
- Prep Time: 5 mins
Cozy Pumpkin Spice Giveaway!
Peanut Butter & Co. is offering an adorable giveaway to one of my readers who love fall, peanut butter, and of course, pumpkin spice! One randomly chosen winner will receive:
- 1 jar of Peanut Butter & Co. Pumpkin Spice peanut butter
- 2 peanut butter spreaders
- a jumbo-sized cozy fall scarf
Use the widget below to enter!
Save this recipe for later! Use the image below to pin this post to your Pinterest boards.
Buddy Garrett
Pumpkin Spice is great for Halloween.
Sand
I love spices but I have to explain that it's not the actual pumpkin flavor that people are in love with, it's just the spices.
Janine Hwang
Pumpkin spice is overrated!
Meme
I like pumpkin spice but maybe they are getting carried away a little.
Christian Alejandro
Although I think it's overrated, I guess whatever gets you into the holiday season is fair.
AEKZ2
Pumpkin spice is awesome!
Trisha McKee
I love love love pumpkin spice! I look forward to autumn and this is one of the many reasons.
Anita Jude
Love it ..Awesome
Kayla Klontz
I think it's way overrated, I like pumpkin, but not on and with everything!
Jake B
I love pumpkin season but some people over do it but hey to each their own YUM
Allison Kusel
Love pumpkin spice!!
amanda whitley
i personally think its way overated, my daughter loves it though
John H.
We like pumpkin flavored foods and drinks.
Jennifer H.
I like pumpkin flavored foods.
Julie Waldron
I think it's a little overrated but my daughter loves it. 🙂
Lily Kwan
I think the pumpkin spice craze is awesome!
Joanna Peter
I like a lot of pumpkin spice stuff, but sometimes it goes over the top.
Jessica W.
Pumpkin Spice is still awesome! One of my favorite things about fall.
Kathy Pease
I love pumpkin spice especially coffee
Lorena Keech
Not my taste, but to each his own.
Shannon
It's awesome to me because I love pumpkin and pumpkin spice. I always look forward to products like this at this time of year.
Shea Balentine
I think it's overrated... I wish everything was more apple cinnamon.. lol =)
stacy
I love everything pumpkin
Jill Rivera
I don't like in my coffee, but I do like the pumpkin spice in my bread.
Shane A
I think it's pretty good. I don't know why it's as popular as it is. I think it's just trendy at the moment.
Mary Gardner
I thin pumpkin spice is awesome!
Eileen Boyce
It's awesome!
Lisa
I am not a fan of pumpkin drinks but I like some things like Pumpkin Cheesecake/Pie
Anny Banouvong
I feel that it is very awesome!!
Jen R
I feel like the pumpkin spice craze is spot on! I love it!
Amy Deeter
Nope i am in love with it. one of my favorite reasons i love Fall so much
Lisa Romine
All pumpkin spice things welcome here!
shawna
Love the craze and love pumpkin!
jberry
I was a fool for my Grandmas pumpkin spice anything. I think most don't hit the mark, esp DD cake doughnuts.
kim keithline
I think its great I love pumpkin spice anything
Laurie Emerson
I think it is awesome. I love everything pumpkin from pumpkin pie to pumpkin bars.
cindy whipple
can't wait to try this flavor
Leela
I look forward to my usual pumpkin treats.
Michelle H.
I think it is a fun change for the cooler weather.
Otila Massaro
I love Peanut Butter, Pumpkin spice is good when it has natural flavorings. Would be very interested to taste these together!
Heather D
I like pumpkin spice but it is way overrated.
susan smoaks
i love pumpkin spice. it is the best.
Ed
Pumpkin Spiice is splendid!
Michelle Hill
The crave is only once a year and I think it is awesome!
brandy c
I love pumpkin spice, I don't see anything wrong with it.
Rebecca C
I think the pumpkin spice crazy is a bit overrated. It's good, but there's just way too much pumpkin spice stuff everywhere now. Enough already haha!
Miz Vickik
It can be a little overwhelming, but it is good!
Lauren
It is awesome!
Susan Christy
It's awesome as long as there is real pumpkin included.
angie w
I like pumpkin spice! Always nice during the Fall
Joseph Gersch
i love it, unique tastes
Erica B.
It's over rated.
Brandy Schwartz
I'm not a fan of pumpkin spice. So, I think it's overrated. But, I know a lot of people love it.
Lauren Olivia Wood
I love the pumpkin spice craze! I try everything I can find!
Mallory Bailey
I personally don't like anything pumpkin but I think it's awesome for those that do! It's a great kick off to fall 🙂
Sherrie Cruson
It's awesome and lately I've been craving pumpkin everything like crazy. I can't seem to get enough! It's definitely Fall 🙂
fran
I just tried pumpkin spice cookies and they were tasty so I'm not complaining!
elizabeth p
I really like pumpkin in baked goods but it has a soap like flavor in drinks.
Beth
If I said I licked my computer screen when I came across a screen of pumpkin spice peanut butter, would that make me weird? I love pumpkin everything...and use it for soups, pasta sauces, breads, muffins, etc. Yesterday my hubby made pumpkin spice coffee while I made pumkin pie bars for breakfast! We have five sons and there's sooo many dishes that we can make off of a single pumpkin!
heather d
I really liked it, but once I saw pumpkin spiced ham I thought it was a bit much.
Kim Avery
I think it's over rated. There are some things I like pumpkin spiced but it's gone too far! I'm sure my son would love this because he is all about everything pumpkin spiced!
Patricia Caradonna
It's awesome and looks delicious! Can't wait to try.
Marty
It depends what it's in. Pumpkin spice is WAY overused, as everyone tries to jump on the bandwagon, whether it's appropriate for their product or not. I saw pumpkin spice cleaning products at the grocery store last year.
Susan P.
I like pumpkin spice in muffins, quick bread and pumpkin pie but not in drinks.
Julie
I think it's awesome!
heather s
I really like it and it is fun this time of year
Robbie
It looks to be awesome
Tari Lawson
I think it is overrated. I like it to a degree, but it is way overdone.
HilLesha
Much as I love pumpkin spice, I can't complain in the least!
Jessica
I love pumpkin spice season! It gets me in the mood for fall even when the weather does not feel like it truly is fall!
Azeem Isaahaque
Mmmm!!! They look so good
Melanie Hook
This looks too yummy!
cyndi br
I think it is awesome
Amy A
I love pumpkin spice, but I think sometimes it's too much.
Brenna
I love their white chocolate pb! It's my favorite!
BARBARA SCOTT
I LOVE PUMPKIN SPICE I THINK IT'S AWESOM,NEVER TRIED IT WITH PEANUT BUTTER.
Natalie R
I love the flavors of pumpkin spice, but I think it's gone a liiiittle too far with some products. Hoping the new maple pecan trend catches on 🙂
karen mayernick
It's awesome! I love it! Thanks for the chance too!
Sandy Klocinski
You know who I want to punch in the throat? PUMPKINS. (If they only had one.)
alice minx
It depends on what it's in.. Certain foods are great that way.. others.. not so much :/
crystle tellerday
pumpkin spice is awesome
Francine
I like it in small doses, but it's starting to become overkill
Cynthia C
I enjoy pumpkin spice flavors but I do think they are overrated.
Cheryl
I like pumpkin spice, but think it's overrated.
Do
I'm not too keen on them, but when the flavor isn't overpowering, pumpkin spice flavor goods are okay.
Cathy Truman
I love Pumpkin Spice it is good on everything
Susan W.
These look yummy! A great alternative to baking where it’s still too warm.
Tracy Shafer
I love pumpkin spice! And people only go crazy for it once a year, so everyone else can just deal!
Debbie E
I like a few pumpkin desserts, but I think it is a little overrated for everything else.
Abigail Gibson
I say AWESOME!
Michelle
This is my favorite PB and I love the pumpkin spice flavor!
Serena Powell
I absolutely love the pumpkin spice trend!
Kenneth Helmick
It's overrated, but I don't see any reason to hate on something people enjoy.