How to Stack Cake Layers | Vanilla Buttermilk Cake

As many of you know, I struggle with making “pretty” food.  Each time I try, there seems to be some hang up along the way that sends my brilliant (not really) ideas into droopy lopsided pitifulness.  However, I was determined to make a birthday cake for Matt and his dad, and figured it was the perfect opportunity to try making something as pleasing to the eye as it is to the palate.

I still encountered some problems, as you’ll no doubt notice when you see the finished product, but I did finally learn how to successfully flatten and stack a somewhat level layer cake.  Here’s what I did…

I started with a couple o’ 6 inch cake pans, filled only halfway with vanilla buttermilk cake batter.  The recipes for everything I used are at the bottom of this post.  I whacked the pans on the counter a few times to let any air bubbles rise to the top.


Once the layers were baked, I let them cool for about 15 minutes on a wire rack, while still in the pans.

I use 3 things to determine cake done-ness:

1. A clean toothpick inserted in a few different places on the cake.

2. A golden but still moist top.

3. Edges that are just slightly starting to pull away from the pan.

 

After the cakes cooled for a bit, I removed them from the pans.  To do this, I placed one hand flat against the top of the cake and inverted the pan in my hands.  The layer came right out.  Depending on the size of your cake, however, you may want to use a large flat pan instead of your hand.  My cake was small, only 6″, so it was easy to hold the entire layer in one hand.

Once removed from the pans, the layers went back onto the wire rack to finish cooling completely.  I added a layer of parchment paper to prevent wire marks on the cake bottoms.

Next, we’ll need to cut off the domed top of each layer so that our cake will stack evenly.  I use this cake knife from Wilton that makes this step a cinch.

I placed one layer on a cardboard cake circle.  This’ll allow you to easily move the cake around once it is stacked.  Then, I crouched down so that I was eye level with the cake.  I put one hand flat on top of the dome while holding the knife in the other hand, parallel to the counter.  Slowly (because you don’t want to mess up the edges of the layer) cut across the top and whack that dome right off.

I’m sure you’ll find something to do with the leftover piece.  I haven’t the slightest clue what that might be, but you’re a smart group of peeps.  You’ll think of something.

Now it’s time to add your filling!  You can either add a flavored filling, or you can fill it with whatever frosting you are using for the outside of the cake.  I used a simple chocolate buttercream, and spread on a good layer using an elongated spatula.

By this time, you should have leveled off your other layer as well.  You’ll want to invert that layer and place it on top of your filling, so that the bottom is facing upwards.  This gives you the flattest possible surface on the top of the cake.  This seems like such an obvious step, but I can’t tell you how many cakes I’ve made where I simply stacked both layers on top of each other, crumb-side up.  You can imagine the crumbs that would get into my frosting as a result of that.

So there you have it.. an easy way to stack a level cake!  The next step is to add the frosting on the outside, and that’s your chance to fill in any gaps between the layers and the filling and give you nice even sides.  This is where I knew I would have difficulty.  I struggle with frosting consistency and usually end up with lumpy sides.  I also tend to use too much pressure when frosting the outside, which ends up knocking my top layer off-center and makes the whole thing lopsided.

All of those above things happened with this cake.  Sigh.  I’ll get there one day.

I used a vanilla buttercream using 100% butter, so it was getting a little droopy and needed to chill.  Here’s my lumpy, slightly lopsided cake hanging out in the fridge for a lil’ while before serving.

The silver lining is that it was super tasty.. buttercream is one of the most delicious substances on Earth, don’t you agree?  I could eat a vat of it just by itself!  The little pearls are these luster decorating pearls from Williams-Sonoma.  Matt gave them to me in my stocking last Christmas and I’m finally getting a chance to use them!

Overall, I think I finally have a handle on stacking layers, and I’ll continue to learn how to successfully frost a cake without making things all lopsided and uneven.    I’ll conquer this feat one day, I’m sure of it!

Here’s your recipes!  I used my favorite recipe for vanilla buttercream, and the cake came from Smitten Kitchen.